Plus: DCCC votes on Engardio recall
San Francisco Standard

Power Play

The OpenAI logo and text appear on a dark screen edge next to blurred black text on a white background mentioning ChatGPT and account creation.

If you feel guilty about using ChatGPT at work, don’t worry: The people running City Hall also lean on AI to do their jobs.

Records obtained by Power Play show that Mayor Daniel Lurie's communications director, Han Zou, has frequently turned to ChatGPT this year with questions on a range of issues: President Donald Trump’s Alcatraz proposal, potential challenges to Lurie’s “family zoning” plan, and logistics of the city charter. 

“What steps must happen for Alcatraz to be converted back to a prison?” Zou asked the AI tool, referencing the president’s pie-in-the-sky plan to reopen the shuttered penitentiary. 

ChatGPT’s response: “It would be a highly complex and politically controversial process.” Zou asked what the vote requirements would be for the Alcatraz plan to take shape, then inquired about the transfer of ownership from the National Park Service to the Bureau of Prisons.

The ChatGPT logs, which were undated and heavily redacted, show the mayor’s office is anticipating tough questions from residents and the press about the plan to build more housing. Zou turned to the AI tool for preparation on fielding those difficult inquiries. 

One sample question the chatbot generated: “Why call this a ‘family zoning’ plan when it appears to rebrand traditional upzoning — what distinguishes this from prior efforts to increase density?” Another possible question: “Given that most families in San Francisco are renters, how does the plan specifically protect or benefit them — not just homeowners or developers?”

Zou also inquired about legal protections for streetcars, asking the AI bot if the light-rail lines are protected in the city charter. (It is much harder to remove something if it is in the charter.) Zou also asked for examples of the “city budget using one-time funds to pay for recurring costs,” likely a question that helped inform Lurie’s budget, which he promised would usher in more prudent spending practices

Asked about the ChatGPT use, Lurie’s spokesperson, Charles Lutvak, deferred to the city’s generative AI guidelines, which encourage double-checking whatever the chatbot spits out and avoiding fake images (no AI memes), among other pointers.

— Gabriel Greschler

Programming note: Power Play will return to your inboxes twice a week in September, starting next Wednesday after the Labor Day weekend. Got tips? Send us an email at powerplay@sfstandard.com.

In the Pipeline

A man in a suit speaks at a podium labeled "Election Rigging Response Act," with a crowd behind him holding signs supporting democracy and voting rights.

THE SAC SUMMIT: Power Play spent a day in the state capital, where temps hovered above 90 degrees, for Politico’s California Agenda: Sacramento Summit.

The nerdfest included conversations with Gov. Gavin Newsom, who touched on his fears for American democracy and how he’s handling Trump’s second term in office. Sen. Alex Padilla joined the summit to provide insight on Trump’s Washington (and dodged repeated questions on whether he will run for governor in 2026). Other panels featured declared gubernatorial hopefuls Xavier Becerra, Katie Porter, and Steve Hilton.

Some highlights: 

“It’s been a hell of a year,” Newsom said at the start of his keynote conversation with Politico’s California editorial director, Christopher Cadelago. Newsom — whose Proposition 50 redistricting measure will be on the Nov. 4 ballot — said he has learned over the last several months that he has to take a more aggressive approach to Trump, whom he called “the most destructive and damaging individual in my lifetime.”

“This is a real and serious moment in U.S. history,” Newsom said. “I say that as an American, not as a Democrat. Every Republican should be ashamed about this and scared to death about not just these authoritarian tendencies but these authoritarian actions by the president.”

“Wake up. We’re losing this country in real time,” he added. “We have to assert ourselves with more clarity and conviction. … That’s what Prop. 50 represents.”

Padilla railed against Trump’s immigration raids in Southern California as "increasingly cruel." As to whether he will jump into the crowded governor’s race? Padilla said he hopes “to continue to serve in some capacity for the foreseeable future,” but said his current focus is on passing Prop. 50. 

Hilton acknowledged that some voters might be “slightly terrified” of a former Fox News host, but the Republican candidate noted his positive relationship with the president and his Cabinet, which could benefit California, and said his focus would be on improving government efficiency. 

Becerra, a former member of Congress and attorney general of California, emphasized his experience as former President Joe Biden’s Health and Human Services secretary during the pandemic and said his focus as governor would be on making sure hardworking Californians can afford insurance and medical treatment. 

Porter, who lost her Senate bid last year, distinguished herself from the crowd with her support for Senate Bill 79, a contentious measure by state Sen. Scott Wiener to build more housing around transit hubs. “We have to build more housing. That is a no-brainer,” she said. "SB 79 is an important step."

Speaking of Wiener, he was part of a housing panel that touched on California’s affordability crisis and, of course, the popular “abundance” movement. He said his colleagues often think he has it easy repping San Francisco, but noted that the city is the “tip of the spear” for resisting housing, which has made it difficult for longtime residents to afford to stay. 

“There is NIMBYism everywhere,” he said. But he noted that San Francisco birthed the YIMBY movement, and said the city made greater progress last November with the election of pro-housing supervisors Danny Sauter and Bilal Mahmood

— Hannah Wiley

FINAL VOTES: At 6:30 p.m. on Wednesday, the San Francisco Democratic County Central Committee will gather in the Bayview for a much-anticipated vote on whether to support the Sept. 16 recall election against District 4 Supervisor Joel Engardio. Here’s the link to watch the meeting.

The party’s endorsement remains one of the most coveted prizes in local politics, and both sides of the recall have been lobbying hard for months to sway the 32-member panel to their column.

Engardio’s camp is confident it has support from the committee’s YIMBY and urbanist blocs that supported the Great Highway’s closure, which prompted the recall. Other members on the board who favor a “no endorsement” are worried that opposing the recall would alienate Sunset voters, particularly Chinese American residents.

It’s hard to overstate the recall’s potential impact. If Engardio is removed from office, Lurie will need to find another moderate as a temporary appointment in order to provide reliable votes for his legislative agenda, including his zoning plan. Notably, DCCC member and former Sunset Supervisor Gordon Mar’s resolution to oppose that plan was yanked from the party’s Wednesday agenda.

On that note, rumors have been spreading faster than Sunset fog on potential Engardio successors.

Among the names being circulated as replacements, either through an appointment or as a candidate in next year’s election: recall organizer Selena Chu, hardware-store owner Albert Chow, Rent Board commissioner Art Tom, educator David Lee, City College board member Alan Wong, real estate agent Jessica Ho, District 10 legislative aide Natalie Gee, former state Assemblymember Phil Ting, Asian Arts commissioner Tiffany Deng, real estate agent Steven Huang, Aaron Peskin mayoral campaign staffer Anthony Leung, and former Together SF staffer Rob Aiavao.

Some names on the list have better odds than others and there’s always the chance that Lurie appoints a “caretaker” supervisor who will provide the mayor with a reliable vote but will decide not to run for a full term next year. 

Meanwhile, about 20 progressive Sunset residents are weighing whom to back in the June 2026 election — including Mar, or a moderate candidate who opposes Lurie’s zoning plan. Sing Tao Daily recently reported that Mar was mulling a comeback, but he later told Mission Local he is “not planning to run.” 

— Han Li and Joe Fitzgerald Rodriguez

In Case You Missed It

An article on Wikipedia about Daniel Lurie highlights a warning that it contains subjective wording affecting real information accuracy.
Diamond bullet

WIKI WHO? A mysterious editor cleansed Lurie’s Wikipedia page of anything remotely unfavorable and added a bunch of press releases from City Hall to highlight his accomplishments in office. Who is Wikiedits84153? 

MORE SWEEPS: City officials struck a deal with Caltrans to clean up encampments along freeways, areas that have mostly eluded forced sweeps. 

NO CHARTER SCHOOL: A proposal to open a Mandarin-immersion charter school failed Tuesday evening when the Board of Education unanimously rejected it.

— Edited by Hannah Wiley

You received this newsletter because you signed up for updates from The San Francisco Standard. Sign up here .

Unsubscribe
|
Terms of Service
|
Privacy Policy
San Francisco Standard Logo
Instagram Social Icon
X Social Icon
Social Icon
TikTok Social Icon
YouTube Social Icon
LinkedIn Social Icon
BlueSky Social Icon

© 2025 The San Francisco Standard, 290 Division Street, San Francisco, CA 94103

beacon