Plus: Wiener appeals to west-side voters
San Francisco Standard

Power Play

A man in a suit is smiling and conversing with another person in a room filled with people, featuring ornate lighting and architectural details.

Supervisor Stephen Sherrill jumped into the hornet’s nest Tuesday night for a Q&A about upzoning in District 2, which covers Presidio Heights, Billionaires’ Row, and other glitzy enclaves. 

The gathering at Calvary Presbyterian Church on Fillmore Street grew tense at times as residents expressed concerns — some more far-fetched than others — over how Mayor Daniel Lurie’s Family Zoning Plan could change their mostly residential neighborhoods. Some worried about the Manhattan-izing of the Marina; one said she feared looking out her window and seeing a skyline like Beijing’s. 

Another outraged resident brought up the recall of Supervisor Joel Engardio, threatening Sherrill with the same treatment if he ignores their concerns.

“You're up for election,” attendee Christophe Bertrand told Sherrill, who was appointed to the board in December by former Mayor London Breed and is running for a four-year term in 2026. “And we know what happens to supervisors who don't listen to their constituents.” The comment elicited both laughter and groans.

Sherrill isn’t the only elected caught between a NIMBY rock and a housing hard place (ahem, Lurie). But the supervisor noted that San Francisco has no choice amid a crackdown from the state. It’s either pass Lurie’s upzoning plan or get ready for Sacramento to start building skyscrapers next to your single-family home via a slew of new state laws that supersede local rules. 

Sherrill chose to make his point in a way that resonated with the audience of mostly seniors: It’s about feeling in control.

“I don't need a bureaucrat in Sacramento to decide the future of San Francisco,” said Sherrill, who noted that the city has to address an aging population and a housing crunch that has made it unaffordable for young people. 

Also at the meeting were Lurie’s state and federal affairs manager, Eileen Mariano; YIMBY advocate Armand Domalewski; SPUR’s director of special projects, Annie Fryman; and former Board of Supervisors president and upzoning opponent Aaron Peskin.

And lurking in the back of the room was Lori Brooke, cofounder of Neighborhoods United SF, known by critics as the queen of the west-side NIMBYs. Rumors had been swirling that Brooke was considering a bid for Sherrill’s seat amid encouragement from development-resistant residents.

She put that speculation to rest Wednesday, texting Power Play to announce that she had pulled papers to run. 

“This city has given us so much, and I’ve spent decades fighting for the neighborhoods that make it such a wonderful place to live,” Brooke wrote. “But lately, City Hall seems to have forgotten who it’s supposed to serve. Our neighborhoods are left out of major decisions that permanently impact our quality of life. Our district deserves an independent, elected voice.”

— Gabe Greschler

Got tips? Send us an email at powerplay@sfstandard.com.

Programming note: Power Play will be off Sunday, Oct. 12, for Indigenous Peoples Day and Columbus Day.

In the Pipeline

Vendors sell their wares on a sidewalk.

VENDING BAN: After Gov. Gavin Newsom signed state Sen. Scott Wiener’s fencing bill this week, Lurie is moving on legislation to clamp down on illegal street vending in San Francisco.

Senate Bill 276, known as the SAFE Streets Act, is Wiener’s second attempt at addressing San Francisco’s stolen-goods markets, which residents contend have flourished in the years since state lawmakers decriminalized street vending. 

SB 276 allows the Board of Supervisors to adopt an ordinance mandating permits to sell commonly stolen merchandise on public property, while giving law enforcement the authority to issue infractions — and a misdemeanor after multiple violations — to individuals who can’t show proof of purchase of goods they’re hawking on the sidewalk. Lurie sponsored the bill. 

“For far too long, we have seen people breaking the law, but we haven’t had the tools at our disposal to do something about it,” Lurie said in an Instagram post Tuesday. “This law allows us to do it.”

Lurie’s spokesperson, Charles Lutvak, said the mayor plans to carry the ordinance, which means first coming up with a list of items commonly tied to stolen goods. Lutvak declined to say which supervisors would be sponsoring the legislation. But the effort is almost sure to generate support from Lurie’s moderate allies, who have voted in line with his crackdown on public safety matters. 

Supervisor Jackie Fielder, a progressive who has butted heads with the mayor on law enforcement issues and whose Mission district is a hot spot for street fencing, indicated that she’s willing to collaborate with the mayor and her moderate colleagues on the issue. 

“I’ll be working with the Mission Street Vendors Association to ensure the list of commonly stolen goods is reasonable, and will continue pushing vending reforms to guard the civil rights of permitted vendors in our community,” Fielder texted Power Play.

— Gabe Greschler

WIENER GOES WEST: The day before Sherrill’s testy town hall, Wiener faced tough questions from residents who’d gathered at Sunset Recreation Center for a conversation focused largely on upzoning (with a smattering of D4 recall politics). 

It wasn’t exactly a crowd of Wiener’s base supporters, who include YIMBY enthusiasts and urbanists supportive of policies like Proposition K. But the Sunset town hall seemed to be part of a strategy by Wiener to shore up support from west-side and Chinese voters before his expected congressional run once Speaker Emerita Nancy Pelosi retires.

His recent outreach to the community has included posting Cantonese-language TikToks and bilingual Chinese content, along with celebrating the Mid-Autumn Festival and participating in press conferences with the Chinese Hospital in Chinatown and Chinese pharmacy store owners in the Richmond.

Even though Wiener’s support for closing the Great Highway to cars and his YIMBY bona fides put him at odds with many west-side residents, he touted strong support from voters across the city. Wiener received nearly 79% of the vote in the November 2024 election (though we’ll note that he received more modest support in some west-side neighborhoods, including the Sunset). 

Wiener emphasized in a statement to Power Play that he has stood with the Asian American community on its priority issues, including his endorsement of the successful 2022 recall of three school board officials. 

“When the time comes, I look forward to making the case to voters and building on the strong citywide support I’ve received in my last three elections for state Senate,” Wiener said. “In the meantime, I’m focused on my work in the Legislature to make housing and healthcare more affordable and prevent transit service cuts.”

— Han Li

BARNES’ DOOR IS OPEN: Bill Barnes told Power Play this week that he’s “definitely taking a look” at jumping into the crowded District 10 supervisor race once there’s more political air time after the Nov. 4 special election for Proposition 50. 

“We’ve gotta get Prop. 50 passed, and I’m all in on that,” the political insider said.

Barnes, 48, managed Ed Lee’s successful mayoral campaign before serving as chief of staff to former Supervisor Ahsha Safaí. Barnes is now director of campaigns and community engagement for the Non-Profit Housing Association of Northern California. 

A 15-year resident of Potrero Hill, Barnes has many City Hall and campaign connections, which, along with his work with community groups, could make him a contender.

He would face a tough competitor in Theo Ellington, a well-known lobbyist and interim executive director of the Ruth Williams Opera House, who declared his candidacy this week. Other candidates include Board of Appeals commissioner J.R. Eppler, community organizer Jameel Rasheed Patterson, and political outsiders Mike Lin and Pearci Bastiany. A progressive is expected to emerge in DJ Brookter, CEO of the nonprofit Young Community Developers, while community organizer Cedric Akbar has told Power Play he’s getting into the race.

Barnes said he expects to make a decision by the end of the year.

“I definitely think I have a path,” he said.

— Josh Koehn

JUST AN UPDATE: Engardio’s last day in office is Oct. 17. It’s unclear when Lurie will make his decision on who will replace the supervisor, but sources say several frontrunners have sat for first-round interviews. Lurie’s communications director, Han Zou, is said to be leading the process.

Lurie’s office remains tight-lipped and has repeatedly declined to share updates on the mayor’s selection process. Lurie attended the Sunset town hall and told residents there to offer their input on who they think should represent D4.

“We have a number of people interested in the seat,” Lurie told the crowd. “We want you all to have representation, so we're moving quickly on this.”

— Han Li

In Case You Missed It

Portraits of diverse professionals arranged in a grid, each labeled with names and some with colored circular accents behind.
Diamond bullet

HOUSE OF CARDS: The Standard set out to document the most crucial people in Lurie’s world, resulting in the most comprehensive collection of his connections yet assembled.

Diamond bullet

MORE MONEY, MORE PROBLEMS: A team of city officials has recommended culling five duplicative homelessness oversight commissions that collectively cost taxpayers $2 million annually to operate — without making much progress on the issue. 

Diamond bullet

STRIKE WATCH: The San Francisco teachers union is threatening to strike after rejecting the cash-strapped school district’s offer of a 2% raise.

— Edited by Hannah Wiley

You received this newsletter because you signed up for updates from The San Francisco Standard. Sign up here .

Unsubscribe
|
Terms of Service
|
Privacy Policy
San Francisco Standard Logo
Instagram Social Icon
X Social Icon
Social Icon
TikTok Social Icon
YouTube Social Icon
LinkedIn Social Icon
BlueSky Social Icon

© 2025 The San Francisco Standard, 290 Division Street, San Francisco, CA 94103

beacon